- David Abrams '85 (2023) - Men's Tennis
- Melvin Allen '69 (2025) - Men's Basketball
- Ralph Batty '72 (2022) - Football
- Bill Burke '93 (2024) - Football
- Yasmin Cooper '17 (2022) - Women's Basketball
- Andrew Dukes '14 (2024) - Men's Soccer
- Clara Forney '19 (2025) - Women's Track & Field
- Frank Gantz '74 (2024) - Men's Basketball
- Corey Gast '08 (2023) - Men's Golf
- Danielle Greene '19 (2024) - Women's Golf
- Karen Gregan '91 (2023) - Women's Volleyball
- Luke Hadfield '90 (2023) - Football
- Jerry Hoff '78 (2023) - Football
- Daniel Ireland '77 (2023) - Wrestling
- Rasheed Johnson '16 (2023) - Football
- Kenneth Kline '53 (2022) - Men's Basketball
- Karl Kramer '52 (2024) - Men's Basketball
- John Kochan '97 (2025) - Men's Basketball Coach
- Steve Koons '85 (2025) - Men's Cross Country/Track & Field
- Aliza Mizak Kulina '19 (2024) - Field Hockey
- Joseph Labatch '56 (2023) - Men's Basketball
- Allan Laskowski Jr. '65 (2024) - Men's Track /Cross Country/Football/Soccer
- Larry Levy '87 (2025) - Men's Track & Field/Cross Country
- Keith Mahaffey '03 (2025) - Men's Tennis
- Darian McCauley '20 (2025) - Men's Soccer
- Wayne McKinney '76 (2023) - Men's Soccer
- Becky Morris McLoughlin '01 (2025) - Women's Soccer
- Erica Tarsi Metz '20 (2025) - Field Hockey
- Eli Nabholz '19 (2025) - Baseball
- Tyler Orris '16 (2022) - Baseball
- Jordan Rigby '14 (2025) - Football
- Robby Rowe '16 (2022) - Men's Golf
- Darren Ryals '97 (2024) - Football
- Amy Seier '94 (2023) - Women's Track and Field
- Taylor Parker Sheehan '17 (2026) - Field Hockey
- Reggie Slaton '15 (2025) - Football
- Connor Sheehan '18 (2024) - Men's Golf/Wrestling
- Brittany Smith '17 (2025) - Softball
- Brooklyn Smith '16 (2024) - Women's Volleyball
- Braden Steffy '04 (2023) - Football
- Mitch Stoltzfus '17 (2023) - Baseball
- Kevin Stover '90 (2023) - Men's Track and Field
- David Summerfield '17 (2023) - Football
- Jayci Suseland '20 (2025) - Women's Volleyball
- Katrina King Swarr '94 (2026) - Field Hockey
- Desi Washington '91 (2023) - Football
- Curtis Yeager '05 (2024) - Wrestling
- Dr. Richard Zinck '75 (2024) - Wrestling
- 1990 Women's Track and Field Team (2022)
Italics denote Old-Timers eligibility
(year nomination submitted)
Updated 7/22/26
Millersville Athletics Hall of Fame Mission
The purpose of the Millersville University Athletic Hall of Fame is to honor and perpetuate the memory of those individuals who, through participation, support, or interest, have made outstanding contributions to Millersville University athletics, and who have helped bring recognition, honor, distinction, or excellence to Millersville University and its intercollegiate athletics program.
The hall of fame's inaugural class was enshrined in 1995, and a committee of alumni, current coaches, and staff elect a new class each year. The class is honored at a banquet on Homecoming weekend. Hall of fame plaques for each inductee can be viewed inside Anttonen Lobby in Pucillo Gymnasium.
